|
Myth
1
|
Franiuk, R., Cohen, D., Pomerantz, E. M. (2002). Implicit
theories of relationships: Implications for relationship satisfaction and
longevity. Personal Relationships, 9, 345-367.
By comparing soul mate theory believers to work-it-out
theory believers this article shows how these beliefs impact a person in
their relationship. Soul mate believers tend to have higher marital satisfaction,
however, their views of their partner tend to be only illusions. They believe
that’s how love should be so they distort what they see their partner doing
to fit in their beliefs. Work-it-out theory believers may have lower marital
satisfaction, however, it is a more realistic satisfaction. This article
was extremely helpful because it showed the impact the soul mate belief
has on a relationship and how it may, in the long run, be bad for the couple.
This fits my research because I have the prescription of the soul mate
myth. Since this article explains how people who believe this myth tend
to see illusions about their partner it helps prove that believing that
there is only one perfect soul mate out there for everyone is also simply
an illusion.
Franiuk, R., Cohen, D., Pomerantz, E. M. (2004). The causal
role of theories of relationships: Consequences for satisfaction and cognitive
strategies. PSPB, 30(11), 1494-1507.
Explains how the soul mate theory tends to lead to
idealization or positive illusions about one’s partner/relationship that
can create a self-fulfilling prophecy. Also explains how the work-it-out
theory leads to realism and proactive coping unlike the soul mate theory
which leads to disillusionment or passive fatalism in the face of difficulty.
Also goes on about those who believe in soul mates rely heavily on initial
satisfaction in a relationship where work-it-out theory believers will
stick it out and see if it will work. They do not rely heavily on initial
satisfaction. This article pointed out facts that the others did not about
the initial part of the relationship. I found this information interesting.
It is kind of repetitive to the first article by Franiuk, Cohen, and Pomerantz
because it is written by the same authors however the experiment is different
and provides different information. This article reinforces some of the
information I learned in the other articles.
Knee, C. R., Nanayakkara, A., Vietor, N. A., Neighbors,
C., Patrick, H. (2001). Implicit theories of relationships: Who cares if
romantic partners are less than ideal?. PSPB, 27(7), 808-819.
This article compares peoples beliefs on destiny (soul
mate) and the belief that a relationship can grow and change. It compares
four different beliefs people tend to have: high growth and destiny belief,
high growth and low destiny belief, low growth and high destiny belief,
and low growth and low destiny belief. It shows how people who don’t believe
in growth or destiny tend to think relationships are doomed from the start.
It puts a lot of emphasis on the cultivation belief (high growth and low
destiny) as the healthy relationship belief. This article was helpful because
it put the belief that a relationship can grow and change along with the
belief of soul mates and shows how these two beliefs combined affect relationships.
I didn’t find this article as helpful as the first article by Franiuk,
Cohen, and Pomerantz because the belief on growth isn’t part of the prescription
of the soul mate myth however it was interesting and slightly helpful.
Galician, M.-L. (2001). Sex, love, and romance in the
mass media: Analysis and criticism of unrealistic portrayals and their
influence. Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
[Chapter 7, pg 119-123, about Myth
#1]
Myth #1 “Your perfect partner is cosmically predestined
so nothing/nobody can ultimately separate you” personifies the ideas of
fate, destiny and soulmates. Galician mentions in her chapter about
myth what she found that her own students belief in the myth as well as
Rutgers University study of marriage which talks about what some people
really believe and how if affects them. The book also has examples of the
myths as well as a good example of the prescription. In the book
it also talks about the origin of the myth from the Greek Gods (Galician,
Ch 2). One thing the book does provide is good examples of the myth in
movies, and how to dis-illusion them. The book also does provide some good
additional research and insight into how Television writers write and why
they write that way. The book is a good place to start but does not help
all that much, it really doesn’t go into great detail about what affects
come from the myth.
Finkel, E. J., Burnette, J. L., & Scissors, L. E.
(2007). Vengefully ever after: Destiny beliefs, state attachment anxiety,
and forgiveness. Journal of Personality & Social Psychology, 92(5),
871-886.
The main focus of the article talks about how state
attachment anxiety, destiny beliefs, and forgiveness and how they are all
intertwined. In the study they talked about how strong destiny
beliefs are found to be negatively correlated with state attachment anxiety,
as well how likely you are to forgive a person based on what exactly you
believe. The article also mentions they difference in ways people react
to romantic offenses based on if they are feeling state attachment anxiety
or state attachment security. The study provides a lot of good information
when it talks about forgiveness and strong destiny beliefs and how they
relate. They give a good explanation of what they found in the study,
and why strong destiny beliefs are negatively correlated with forgiveness.
It gives good insight into the thought process of a person who holds strong
destiny beliefs. They could have done a better job of explaining the difference
between state attachment anxiety and state attachment security.
Franiuk, R., Cohen, D., & Pomerantz, E. M. (2002).
Implicit theories of relationships: Implications for relationship
satisfaction and longevity. Personal Relationships, 9(4), 345-367.
In this particular study they talk about three types
of theorists, soulmate, destiny and work-it-out, and how they view satisfaction
in a relationship. The study mentions the five main notions that soulmate
theorists, and work-it-out theorists hold and how they are different.
In this article it also talks about how perception is altered when a they
hold strong soulmate and destiny beliefs. It also mentions many of
the negative affects of holding strong beliefs soulmate beliefs on a relationship.
The article and study had a lot of good information about how perception
plays a key role in happiness in a relationship. They article also
mentions about conflict and as well as the belief about a partner being
able to change. It also cited many good sources. The cited sources
provided more information and more detail in how perception affects a relationship
satisfaction. The article can be kind of confusing at times, but really
helpful.
Murray, S. L., Holmes, J. G., & Griffin, D. W. (1996).
The benefits of positive illusions: Idealization and the construction of
satisfaction in close relationships. Journal of Personality Social Psychology,
70(1), 79-98.
This study is a really interesting study about how
people press positive illusions on their partners to make their partner
seem more perfect. It also talked about how since they saw their
partner is a more positive light they found that they had more satisfaction
in a relationship. The article talks about how positive illusions can be
good and bad for relationship. The article provided me with some really
good information involving the use of positive illusions in a relationship.
It was very helpful when it talked about how people like to put the positive
illusions on their partners to make sure they had more relationship satisfaction.
Another useful part of the article is when they mentioned that people might
distort flaws to keep the positive illusions, and how this is harmful. |
|
Myth
2
|
Barelds, D.P.H. & Barelds-Dijkstra, P. (2007).
Love at first sight or friends first? Ties among partner personality,
trait personality, relationship onset, relationship quality, and love.
Journal of Social and Personal Relationships, 24(4), 479-496. Retrieved
October 17, 2007, from Academic Search Premier.
This article focused on a study done by Dick Barelds
and Pieternel Barelds-Dijkstra researching how being friends first, having
an ‘in between’ relationship, or falling in love at first sight affects
partner similarity. The article goes into some background information
about personality, trait similarity, relationship onset, relationship quality,
and love before telling about the study they conducted. Barelds and
Barelds-Dijkstra then tell about the methods they used in their study,
the results of the study, and finally they discussed some pertinent facts
that the reader should know. In their article, there were also easy-to-understand
tables with statistics of the results. This was a very useful article
for my research on love at first sight, and the dangers it brings.
There was some confusion with understanding parts of their study, but for
the most part it was easy to figure out. Overall, I felt that this
article was one of my more useful sources. It gave me mostly statistics,
but those are nice to understand what affects love at first sight can really
have in a relationship.
Galician, Dr. M.L. (2004). Sex, love, and romance
in the mass media. United States: Dr. Mary-Lou Galician.
Dr. Mary –Lou Galician’s book, Sex, Love, and Romance
in the Mass Media, was an extremely helpful source for helping me understand
the prescription more, and that is probably because she came up with this
prescription! The section I focused on was chapter eight, discussing
love myth number two and its prescription. There were many good examples
of where people can see love at first sight in the media, and how we can
avoid ‘falling’ into love. This source was my most useful source
overall. Galician is very clear about what she wants readers to know
about both the myth and prescription, and is also reliable since she is
the writer of these myths and prescriptions. I feel that this was
a great source also because Galician is concise but very accurate and easy
to follow.
Horton, Donald (1957). The dialogue of courtship
in popular songs. American Journal of Sociology, 62, 569-578.
This article was useful to read because it talked about
how love and problems concerning love show up in a countless number of
songs. This article was written in 1957 and Horton’s study was actually
done in 1955. Although this study is old, it shows how even in the
1950s, the media was influencing it’s listeners through song. Horton
points out how the language in songs focuses on and manipulates adolescents.
This book was useful to support my point about how the media really influences
people into believing unrealistic ways of love. We know that this
study is reliable because Horton not only states his findings, but cites
other reliable sources to support his own findings. I liked this
source because it gave a sense of reality and related the media of the
past with the media of the present. I didn’t understand how much
and how long the media has manipulated listeners, but Horton’s article
really opened my eyes.
Sternberg, R.J. (1998). Cupid’s arrow: The course
of love through time. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
Robert J. Sternberg, an expert on love, shows more
of his expertise through his 1998 book, Cupid’s Arrow: The Course of Love
through Time. The book focuses on different aspects of what love
is and how love develops, continues and then ends in our lifetimes.
Cupid’s Arrow was very useful to my research because it had examples of
a variety of the love myths and also went into good depth on the different
topics Sternberg discussed within his book. Sternberg also does a
good job of citing other sources to support what he has found. In
the book, Sternberg also adds diagrams to support his points. This
book is reliable because Sternberg has done such extensive research on
love, and has published many books and articles about his studies.
I would use this book again for research on any love myth.
Barelds, D. P. H., & Barelds-Dijkstra, P. (2007).
Love at first sight or friends first? ties among partner personality trait
similarity, relationship onset, relationship quality, and love. Journal
of Social & Personal Relationships, 24(4), 479-496.
This particular source of information that I used on
my presentation of the media love myth, “There is such thing as love at
first sight”, discussed a study of couples and how they first met and how
well they know each other. This study showed that the couples who
fell in love at first sight had more dissimilar personalities, then couples
who gradually entered a relationship and were friends first. The
dissimilar personalities showed a lower relationship quality compared the
couples with more similar personalities. The couples who were friends
first also knew their mate better then the couples who became romantically
involved first. This article helped me in my research of the myth
because it proves that if couples are friends first they have a greater
chance of a successful and higher quality relationship. The authors
of this article are highly educated and did extensive research for this
study. They also have many reliable sources and data to back up their
conclusion about this love myth. This particular source was the most
helpful and useful to support the love myth #2.
Perina, K. (2007). The first five seconds. Sussex Publishers
Inc
This editorial has a story about a couple who
fell in love at first sight and lived happily ever after. It also
describes love at first sight in a very interesting way. There are
also interviews from couples who have fallen in love at first sight and
how they knew right away that they were meant for each other. This
particular research article was not as helpful as other articles.
It conveyed only the stories that couples who fell in love at first sight
were happily married and nothing went wrong in their relationships.
Although Petrina describes love at first sight as a gut instinct, so we
are unable to not “fall in love”. We also are aware that it
is only a physical attraction not actual love. This article is supportive
in some aspects but also conveys that love at first sight can actually
happen and shows many stories of successful relationships that have started
off of a physical attraction and makes them seem like a fairy tale.
It relates to my myth because it has stories of love at first sight and
many different insights about love at first sight. Although it doesn’t
necessarily support that love at first sight is a myth, this article provided
me with a good definition of love at first sight, and it also was a very
dependable source.
Lasting love takes effort and skill.(1995). USA Today
Magazine, 123(2599), 3.
The article from USA Today Magazine showed many
different options for couples to overcome differences in their relationships.
These differences may be caused by a lack of similar personalities.
Although physical attraction is said to be the starting point of a relationship,
this article provides many relationship skills for a couple to try to make
a relationship to grow and last. It also points out that love
takes time and commitment, not just a physical attraction. Lasting love
takes effort and skill. This statement supports that love at
first sight is a myth, not reality. This source helped me in many
ways by providing tips for couples to help their relationships, and stating
that love takes much more than just attraction. This source related
to my research because it agrees with the thought of love at first sight
isn’t reality, but a myth. This magazine article was very helpful
to my presentation of the love myth and gave me ideas and examples to use
in my speech. |
|
Myth
3
|
Galician, M.-L. (2001). Sex, love, and romance in the
mass media: Analysis and criticism of unrealistic portrayals and their
influence. Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
[Chapter 9, pp. 135-144, about Myth #3]
Myth #3, “your soul mate should know what you’re thinking
and feeling(without your having to tell), is the idea of mind reading within
a relationship. Because of how media portrays relationships many people
strive to achieve the same Hollywood love life but are disappointed by
the effort needed to communicate properly. Galitian states the cure is
to communicate and talk about what you want and don’t want instead of assuming
that your partner will figure it out. She gives a few examples in media
such as What Women Want and Dr. T and Women that support the claim of thorough
communication being needed. The chapter is a basic reference for the idea
of communication in a relationship and furthered research is needed to
reach a scholarly level of presentation. (129)
Emmert Phillip, Brooks. Interpersonal Communication
1980, W. C. Brown Co., Dubuque, Iowa, 2nd Ed.
This book, although being on the old side and nearly
outdated, offered substantial examples of myth #3 affecting society. The
example found about WWII soldiers and “easy” girls was a unique and interesting
additive to support the information I provided. There were other credible
examples, too, and although the information is old I found it in agreement
with some of the same information I found in other books and was able to
align it with all the other evidence I found. (81) There was also information
about nonverbal behaviors and communication which aligned with the book
Gender and Nonverbal Behavior but the information was not as organized
and structured. The book did provide a good basic understanding of the
myth because of the examples used because of their uniqueness. (129)
Henley, Nancy, Mayo, Clara. Gender and Nonverbal Behavior.
1981, Springer-Verlag, New York
This book offers an in depth explanation and detailed
experiments that validate the myth of a soul mate reading one’s mind. This
book is on the old side also but some of the same information is found
in this book which is found in other researched media I have found. There
are many experiments that are described in the text and there is a mixture
of good and bad experiments; some are reliable and validated while others
remain inconclusive or biased. The book is somewhat of a catalog of experiments
dealing with human behavior with specific instances of situations involving
human behavior, such as female and male interpretations which I found useful.
This book offered credible experiments which would support my claims and
credibility as a speaker. (127)
Meyers, Nancy. What Women Want. 2000, Paramount
Pictures and Icon Productions, Hollywood, CA
After an accident makes Nick Marshall read minds of
women he manipulates the women in his life in order to achieve a greater
lifestyle and to advance himself. The movie depicts Nick, for the first
time in his life, able to understand women but then counteracts this and
gives him confusion yet. He ends up falling in love with the woman he despises
after trying to sabotage her and declares his love to her. The ending is
the romantic story ending with the two falling in love but this just provides
the idea of changing a beast into a man. In a deeper reading of the story
one sees that relational conflict is a big issue to the idea of a satisfactory
romance between a couple. This media worked well as to provide a supportive
idea of the myth yet also involved other myths. (141)
Spielberg, Steven. Saving Private Ryan 1999, Dreamworks,
Paramount Pictures, Universal City, CA
This movie is about searching for a WWII soldier in
order to save his mother from having lost all of her sons in the war. It
is a very accurate description of the war and the lives of the soldiers
and represents truths of WWII that were often hidden or not talked about.
Although the story has very little to do with the myth, an example is found
when soldiers find the European girls “easy.” This was used to reinforce
the examples of WWII soldiers in the book Interpersonal Communication.
This was especially a good example because of the amount of people that
could relate to the movie because it was a large grossing movie. For those
that hadn’t seen it, they could still relate. I found this movie to be
a small additive to increase my credibility. (138) |
|
Myth
4
|
Brooks, G.R. (1995). The centerfold syndrome. San
Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
Brooks states that many males suffer from what is called
“The centerfold syndrome,” and this goes along with myth number 5. It talks
about how the belief in this myth causes them to not be able to have successful
relationships with women. It gives steps to overcome this syndrome and
how to manage good relationships. It gives examples on relationships that
have overcome this syndrome and then others that have not been so successful.
This book is helpful in demonstrating that there will always be part of
relationships that need work. The author spoke of how he once stayed in
a relationship because the sex was satisfactory. He thought that since
the sex was great and that he was physically attracted to his partner,
every other part of the relationship would fall into place. That however
did not happen. This is the opposite of myth number 4. I feel that this
helps disprove my myth greatly. It was more focused on myth number 5, but
had some points for myth number 4 also.
Shapiro, J. & Kroeger, L. (1991). Is life just a romantic
novel? The relationship between attitudes about intimate relationships
and the popular media. The American Journal of Family Therapy, 5, 3, 226-236.
This article is about a study that was done to see
how media and unrealistic beliefs about romance. There were three beliefs
that were commonly believed by people: Mind Reading Is Expected, Sexual
Perfectionism, and Disagreement is Destructive. The study found that people
who state that they have media in their lives also believe these myths.
This article helped me by showing me how many people really do believe
myth number 4. It talks about how the media may make a person feel like
the relationship they are in is not good enough or that they are stuck.
It was also shown that people who listen to rock music, read self-help
books, or watch daytime television are more susceptible to believe this
myth.
Straus, J. (2006). Unhooked generation: The truth about
why we’re still single. New York: Hyperion.
Straus analyzes what she calls the “unhooked generation.”
She states that there are many beliefs that are causing our generation
to not be able to have successful relationships. There are many unachievable
qualities or expectations that we are looking for in a future partner.
Many people make checklists of qualities that they would like fulfilled
and if all the qualities are not achieved, they decide to move on. This
book talks about that people need to realize this syndrome and also how
they can move on to better and happier lives. This book supports
the thought that there are many myths or beliefs people have that have
a negative effect on relationships. It does specifically talk about how
people are looking for good sex. They have become more adventurous and
are only seeking pleasure. If they find sex that is satisfying, then they
think about finding starting or committing to relationship. Since they
are only seeking the sex first many relationships do not work out because
they are not willing to work in other aspects of the relationships.
Eidelson, R. J., & Epstein, N. (1982). Cognition and
relationship maladjustment: Development of a measure of dysfunctional relationship
beliefs. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 50, 715-720. Retrieved
october 18, 2007, from psychinfo.
Eidelson and Epstein explain the harmful effects of
unrealistic beliefs in a relationship. The article describes the basic
concepts of five commonly believed myths about intimate relationships.
These beliefs include: disagreement is destructive, mind reading is expected,
partners cannot change, sexual perfectionism, and the sexes are different.
Eidelson and Epstein conducted a Relationship Belief Inventory (RBI), where
a number of participants were analyzed to determine correlation between
the dysfunctional beliefs and satisfaction in an intimate relationship.
The study found that there is a positive correlation between belief in
these myths and relationship dissatisfaction. This article relates directly
to prescription number four because it discusses the notion of sexual perfectionism
and the dangers of believing in such a concept. Eidelson and Epstein’s
research is helpful in that it discusses the belief of sexual perfectionism,
explains what it is and the harmful effects of the belief, and gives concrete
statistics relating to this information. The research in the article was
conducted with a careful procedure and a random selection of participants.
The article specifies the exact process of calculation and clearly explains
all results and procedure. Even though the article is a little dated, the
Relationship Belief Inventory is strong, reputable research that is still
commonly used.
Shapiro, J., & Kroeger, L. (1991). Is life just a
romantic novel? the relationship between attitudes about intimate relationships
and the popular media. The American Journal of Family Therapy, 19, 226-236.
Retrieved october 18, 2007, from psychinfo.
This article includes information related to the twelve
love myths and specifically the
effects that media has on dysfunction beliefs. The
article describes the results for a study conducted to analyze the relationship
between couple satisfaction and media exposure. The study more specifically
analyzes the correlation between Relationship Belief Inventory scores and
media use. The article specifically addresses sexual perfectionism and
its relation to media exposure. In depth analysis found the dysfunction
belief in sexual perfectionism often stemmed from specific media: rock
music and self help books. Rock music influenced this belief more than
any other media. Self help books also increased the belief in sexual perfectionism.
This research directly relates to the thesis of the speech because it proves
that belief in sexual perfectionism is indeed unhealthy and that the prescription
for these dysfunctional beliefs is necessary. Later in the article, suggestions
are given to disregard dysfunction beliefs. It suggests that people raise
awareness about the media and accept the fact the media does influence
us. This source is very helpful and it includes many specific examples
for each dysfunctional belief. It not only explains the results from the
study, it also gives solutions for the dysfunctional beliefs.
Sternberg, R. J. (1986). A triangular theory of love.
Psychological Review, 93, 119-135. Retrieved october 18, 2007, from
psychinfo.
Sternberg’s article gives a very in depth explanation
of his triangular theory of love. He begins by giving an overview of the
three necessary components of consummate love. He explains the importance
of all three elements together in a relationship and then goes on to explain
the types of love that come as a result of missing components. The article
clarifies basis of his research and theory. Later, he compares his theory
to other famous love theories. This article has lots of important information
that relates directly to the thesis for this topic. Sternberg’s triangle,
including the three necessary aspects of love, is a model for a healthy
romantic relationship. The theory explains that sex/passion is an important
and necessary part of a relationship but it is not the only aspect. Without
the other aspects, love is merely infatuation. Sternberg uses other research
to support his own extensive research to prove that his theory is very
credible. Robert J. Sternberg is the author of this article and the creator
of the theory. All explanations within the article are valid because they
are Sternberg’s direct words. Sternberg is notorious for his triangular
theory of love. |
|
Myth
5
|
Grogan, S. (1999). Body image. New York: Routledge.
This book is about body image in people, specifically
about dissatisfaction in men, women, and children. It looks at how body
image is different in each gender, as well as how it is affected by the
culture, the mass media, age, social class, and ethnicity. The author,
Sara Grogan, is the Senior Lecturer in Psychology at Manchester Metropolitan
University. This book is very strong in its evaluation of body image and
the effect that it has on different people. Throughout her book, Grogan
cities many different studies that have been conducted in many different
settings and by many different people. She also provides many vivid examples
that are often accompanied by illustrations, which make the examples easier
to understand. She concludes with ways to develop a more positive body
image, which was helpful when researching the prescription.
Park, S-Y., Yung, G. W., McSweeney, J. H., & Gunther,
A. C. (2007). Do third-person perceptions of media influence contribute
to pluralistic ignorance on the norm of ideal female thinness?. Sex Roles,
57, 569-578. Retrieved October 17, 2007, from academic search premier.
This article is about a study done by the four people
that wrote the article. The study that they did investigates people’s ignorance
of the ideal body image for women and how media messages are the cause
of this misperception. It describes what exactly was done during the study,
how it was done, and the different conclusions that were made about things
such as the perceived norm of ideal female thinness among different groups,
and the influence that the media played in those perceptions. All of the
authors are part of the Communications department at either Bowling Green
State University, or University of Wisconsin, Madison. This source has
a very strong study that can be used in many different ways to better understand
this myth. It goes very in depth and gives all of the specifics about the
study and the conclusions drawn from that particular study. It is a very
useful first hand source.
Wolf, N. (1992). The beauty myth. New York: First Anchor
Books ed.
This book first talks about the beauty myth in general
and then it talks about the myth in many different aspects. It talks about
it in a work setting, as well as in regards to culture, religion, sex,
hunger, violence and beyond. It also talks about how images of beauty are
used against women. The part that I found most helpful was the chapter
called “Beyond the Beauty Myth” which talks about how we can change our
beliefs about beauty. Naomi Wolf graduate from Yale and has written many
other books on similar issues. This book is helpful because it talks about
why women feel pressure to look a certain way. The prescription to the
beauty myth is discussed as well. Wolf gives specific examples of how to
change your perception beauty. This book is very empowering for women of
all ages and in many different stages of life.
Bessenoff, G. R., & Del Priore, R. E. (2007). Women,
weight, and age: Social comparison to magazine images across the
lifespan. Springer Science and Business Media, 56, 215-222. Retrieved Oct.
16, 2007, from Carl B. Ylvisaker Library.
This article discusses how the media affects women,
particularly younger women. They support the idea that the way the media
projects models effects how young women learn to accept body image and
what is appropriate. They also discuss how a great deal of pressure is
put on young women to look thin because that’s what will make them acceptable
in society. Only when they have achieved this perfection will they be accepted
by society, both women and men. This article pertains to my myth, that
a women should look like a model or centerfold, in that is discusses how
the social norm has made women think that to be accepted they must look
a certain way. It will destroy relationships because women don’t believe
in an inner attractiveness, they believe in what that have been taught
matters, which is the exterior. It also helps support the idea of
social comparison, because the women are so affected by what they are seeing
that it changes their views both emotionally and socially.
Galician, M. L. (2004). Sex, love, and romance in the
mass media. Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
Myth number five, “To attract and keep a man, a woman
should look like a model or centerfold,” projects the idea that women must
have the ideal body to be accepted both by men and society in general.
The media reinforces this idea by constantly showing images of ultra thin
women who are happily in relationships. They also project women who aren’t
this ideal as the goof ball who can’t have a man and is seen as more of
the friend figure. The idea is also perpetuated greatly in magazines by
the perfect bodies that are on the covers of both men’s and women’s magazines.
Women see this and think that since it is projected to both sexes that
is what they need to become because that is what’s normal. This information
is helpful in that it gives the basic information and defines myth number
five. While the research isn’t particularly in depth it gives good beginning
ideas and references to what focuses can be taken with further research.
Grogan, S. (1999). Body image: Understanding body dissatisfaction
in men, women, and children. New York: Routledge.
This book talks a great deal about how the media has
affected body image in women. Grogan talks about how women are portrayed
on a much more ideal basis then men are and how that effects what women
believe they should look like in a relationship. She also puts a great
emphasis on how the media has connected having perfect looks with having
happiness and being socially acceptable as well as just how much the media
influences compared to other sources such as friends and family. Grogan
also gives background and examples in connection with social comparison
theory. This book is helpful in understanding my topic in that it compares
how men and women are portrayed differently and how women have a much stricter
image to adhere to. It also clarifies how the media promotes being thin
as being happy and having that “perfect” relationship; along with how much
the media really influences us day to day. The book also offers understanding
of the social comparison theory, which relates to why we are so affected
by the media.
Wykes, M., and Gunter, B. (2005). The media and body image.
London: Sage Publications Ltd.
In The Media and Body Image Wykes and Gunter discuss
how the acceptance of ultra thin women started in the mid 1990’s and continues
through to today. They also discuss how magazines portray an unrealistic
image of what is possible in life with articles about losing fifteen pounds
and making your marriage better. The magazines also promote articles about
addressing a “problem body” which is actually a normal, healthy body. Wykes
and Gunter also discuss how they found that magazines targeting young girls
also fixate and body image and sex. There is also a section discussing
social comparison theory, particularly in relation to magazines. This book
is helpful in relation to my topic because it discusses how the infatuation
with an ultra thin body began. The book also gives a great deal of examples
of how magazines promote unrealistic ideas and images of what the normal
body should be like. Wykes and Gunter and comment on how these ideas are
promoted to girls beginning at a very young age, which supports the idea
that these ideas are ingrained in the minds of women from a very young
age. This book again also has a great deal on the social comparison theory,
particularly in relation to magazines, which helps clarify both the theory
and one of my media examples. |
|
Myth
6
|
Nadler L.B., Nadler M.K., & Todd-Mancillas, W.R.
(1987). Advances in Gender and Communication Research. Lanham, MD: University
Press of America.
In this book Advances in Gender and Communication
Research, it discusses the similarities of the sexes rather then the less
often differences. The book is broken down into five different parts about
genders and the way they communicate. Those five parts are; “The Role of
Gender in Organizational Communication,” “Gender Issues in Interpersonal
and Professional Relationships,” “Gender and Advocacy,” “The Communicative
Influence of Gender on Politics and Culture” and “Gender Communication
Pedagogy.” The one that helped the most with my speech on creating coequality
in the relationships was the section that discussed Gender Issues in Interpersonal
and Professional Relationships. This section talked about empowerment to
both of the sexes in the work place. It also states the benefit of having
balanced personal relationships can lead to success in professional relationships
and vise versa.
Bianchi, S.M., Robinson, J.P. & Milkie, M.A. (2006).
Changing Rhythms of American Family Life. New York: Russell Sage Foundation.
In the next book that I used for my myth
speech it discusses parenting and how it has changed. In one specific chapter
of the book it states many old myths about parenting, and how it should
be a balanced team effort and not one sided. This book Changing Rhythms
of American Family Life goes very in depth about the new revolution of
stay-at-home fathers. With talking about that subject it states how a male
has to have a high level of confidence and tons of self esteem to be able
to hold this normally female position. The author writes about gender equality
and each partner having their “role specialization.” That chapter goes
more in depth in talking about the male and female both having equal amounts
of control in power to create a healthy relationship. Overall this book
gave very good information on how roles in the family have changed and
the many benefits of that transformation.
Brothers, B.J. (1992). Equal Partnering: A Feminine Perspective.
New York: Harrington Park Press.
The other book Equal Partnering: A Feminine Perspective
was very helpful for there were chapters in the book that were basically
stating my myth and its prescription. It discussed in on section partnership
and ego equality in the marital system. In that chapter the author created
a term “Ego Equality” and that it meant that an individual has the ability
to be a peer and to engage in peer interactions. This book also helped
a lot in the prescription aspect for it stated many empowerments themes
for couples. This particular chapter discussed the empowerment process
in which all participants in the relationships interact in a manner which
establishes connection. Also empowerment strengthens each person’s sense
of self worth and personal power. In general this book helped me extremely
with my prescription, for its main focus was on the concept of relationships
between couples with equal partnering as a goal. |
|
Myth
7
|
Levinson D, Ponzetti JJ (Eds). (1999). Encyclopedia
of human emotions, Volume 1. New York: Macmillan Reference USA.
This is an encyclopedia full of different emotions
listed in alphabetical order, each with its own description. For
myth #7 (“the love of a true and faithful woman can change a man from a
beast to a prince”) I used information under “emotional abuse.” This
encyclopedia gives you insight on facts about the emotion, how you can
tell the emotion is being displayed, why someone may feel this emotion,
and (for emotions like emotional abuse) it lists ways to help people get
out of a bad situation. One nice thing about this encyclopedia is
that it covers a lot of topics with statistics and illustrations, but there
are only about 10-15 pages on each emotion. It is really helpful
because they list a lot of facts and organize the information in an easy
to use way compared to having to skim through a book to find key words.
Levy B. (Ed). (1990). Dating violence: Young women in
danger. Seattle, Washington: Seal Press.
This book acts as a self help guide for young women.
With stories from women who used to be involved in abusive relationships,
to stories from teachers who noticed a personality change in their student,
this book acts as a way to show that dating violence is too common, and
lends a hand for those who need help getting out of a relationship to giving
ideas on how other people can help those who don’t know how to help themselves.
It gives a variety of stories like a young girl who was murdered by her
boyfriend, to a teacher who helped her student leave a boy who wasn’t treating
her right. It shows examples of what can happen to girls if they
do not leave that “beast.” There is also a big section on programs
that are out there to help people in abusive relationships, which many
other books I cited did not do. This book gives facts about abusive
relationships, how to notice if someone is in a bad relationship, and where
to go for help.
Gaddis DS. (2000). Dangerous Dating: Helping young women
say no to abusive relationships. Wheaton, Illinois: Harold Shaw Publishers.
Patricia Gaddis is the director of woman’s shelter
and is a certified crisis intervention counselor. She has been involved
in helping women for the last decade and wrote a book on how to help young
girls read the signs of a dangerous relationship. She knows that
the love of a true and faithful women can get severely hurt from an abusive
man whether there is love in the relationship or not. She wrote this
as a guide for others to prevent relationship abusive, because it is a
common occurrence now. Unlike the other books I found about women
in unhealthy relationships, Patricia Gaddis makes people aware of signs
of an abusive relationship that are usually missed by other people.
The strength of this book is just how real she writes. She gives
startling facts about relationships, but also examples of relationships
that start out as normal as ever. This is a great book to use for
examples of what can happen in a relationship, and how everyone can help.
Crompton, V., & Kessner, E.Z. (2003). Saving beauty
from the beast. New York: Crompton and Kessner.
This book discusses the prevalence of teenage dating
violence, dating violence prevention, and interpersonal relations in adolescence.
The authors, Crompton and Kessner, state reasons why teenagers are accepting
emotional and physical abuse. A few of those reasons are low-self
esteem and media influences. One out of five teenage girls is a victim
of physical abuse. When you add in threats and emotional abuse, two
out of three teenage girls are victims. These statistics were cited
by a survey conducted by the National Coalition Against Domestic Violence.
Since the belief in this myth underlies dating violence, according to researches
such as Galician, this book helped in my research about why dating violence
is occurring in teenagers and how we can prevent it. Vicki Crompton
is a strong supporting of teen dating violence education, and she is also
a consultant to the Office of Violence Against Woman in the U.S. Department
of Justice. This book provides background knowledge to how believing
in myth number 7, changing a man from a “beast” into a “prince”, can be
detrimental.
Slagle, R.A., & Yep, G.A. (2007). Taming brian:
Sex, love, and romance in Queer as folk. In M. Galician & D. L. Merskin
(Eds.), Critical thinking about sex, love, and romance in the mass media
(pp.194-195). Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
The authors, Slagle and Yep, analyze Galician’s myth
and prescription number 7. They argue that one of the dangers of
believing in this myth can lead to the responsibility of changing a relationship
be placed on just the woman. They say that the woman believes she
is not good enough or trying hard enough if she fails in changing her significant
other to a better person. Slagle and Yep say that people are responsible
for their own behaviors, not the behaviors of other. This statement
supports Galician’s prescription, “cease correcting and controlling; you
can’t change others (only yourself)”. People need to decide whether
to stay in relationship without trying to change another person’s way of
living. This chapter is helpful in that it refers to Galician’s myth
and prescription number seven, explains the prescription in more detail
than Galician, and supports the prescription. Dr. Slagle researches
communication and gender, and he has won an award from the Speech Communication
Association for his research in communication. Dr. Yep, a Professor
of Speech and Communication Studies at San Francisco State University,
has had his work in many journals and anthologies such as Journal of Social
Behavior and Personality, for example. Their research for this particular
chapter is cited by 25 reliable references.
Sullivan, B. F., & Schwebel, A. I. (1995). Relationship
beliefs and expectations of satisfaction in marital relationships: Implications
for family practitioners. The Family Journal, 3(4), 298-305.
This article explained the findings of two studies
that measured the relationship expectations of young adults, the level
of unrealistic beliefs, and their satisfaction in their current relationship.
One couple went to therapy and lowered their expectations by creating a
set of favorable expectations; now they are in a healthier relationship.
This article helped me because in order to explain my prescription, I needed
to find healthier approaches to relationship problems. The authors,
Sullivan and Schwebel, state that the unrealistic expectations that people
hold only lead to dissatisfaction in their relationships. They support
Galician’s prescription by saying we should focus on fixing ourselves rather
than fixing our significant other. Bryce Sullivan is a doctoral student
in psychology and Andrew Schwebel is a professor in the department of psychology
at Ohio State University. Their research in this article is support
by 36 references with many being reliable journals. The findings
of Sullivan and Schwebel are similar to the article written by Slagle and
Yep. |
|
Myth
8
|
Bartusis, M. A. (1991). Off to a good start: A guide
for engaged couples and newlyweds of all ages. New York: Donald I. Fine,
INC.
This book was written as a guide for newly engaged
or married couples to help them through different conflicts and issues
that may arise in their relationships. It discusses how important
first impressions are, ways to communicate problems, sexual intimacy in
relationships, work verses leisure time, money, children, dealing with
in-laws and other relatives, planning weddings and honeymoons, and lastly
the first year after the wedding. This source is about helping out
couples with different problems that may come up in the beginning stages
of their lives together. I used this book for its chapter on communication
in couples. In this chapter it talks about the different ways to
communicate with your spouse or partner. It also talks about divorce.
It provided me with specific reasons why divorce is a bad way to handle
conflict while also providing information on ways to communicate. Mary
Ann Bartusis is a psychiatrist that provides marital and sex therapy.
She is a Clinical Associate Professor of Psychiatry at the Medical College
of Pennsylvania.
Cupach, W. R. & Canary, D. J. (2007) Couple relationships.
Retrieved October 22, 2007, from dogpile.
This article is all about conflict in relationships
and how people should deal with it. The article talks about different
marital problems and reasons why these problems may arise. It talks
about how stress in relationships is a major problem and one of the major
reasons why conflict arises. The article also talks about divorce
and behaviors that impact conflict in relationships. Defensiveness
is another big topic they talk about. They discuss how defensiveness
can lead to conflict and divorce. William R. Cupach is a professor at the
University of Southern California. He is very interested in conflict
management and interpersonal communication. Daniel J. Canary is the editor
for Sage Publications.
Gottman, J. M. (1994). What predicts divorce? The relationship
between marital processes and marital outcomes. Hillsdale, New Jersey:
Erlbaum.
This book was written in order to help couples understand
marriage and the conflicts that arise in marriages. It also talks
about how to properly deal with conflict. This book covers many different
topics. These topics range from what a healthy marriage is to what
types of behaviors can predict unhealthy and unstable marriages.
The book concludes with recommendations for a stable marriage. While
researching I used the chapters title “Marital Processed That Predict Disillusion”
and “Is Conflict Avoidance Dysfunctional”. These chapters provided
background information about conflict in relationships. I used these
chapters to also figure out what behaviors predict conflict in relationships
and even divorce. Gottman has been studying marriage and couples
for over three decades. He is a professor at the University of Washington.
He is a Professor Emeritus of Psychology. He founded the family research
lab and the co-founder of the Gottman Institute.
Galician, M.-L. (2004). Sex, love, and romance in the
mass media: Analysis and criticism of unrealistic portrayals and their
influence. Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
Galician’s book was essential in my presentation.
It was her myth #8 that stated “Bickering and fighting lot mean that a
man and woman really love each other passionately” This was the background
to the information that I presented. The point that she drove home behind
this myth was that conflict is normal and should occasionally happen in
a relationship. Her example of the using the ratio 5:1 states that
for every five positive interactions you should have one negative one as
well. In this chapter she uses many different examples to convey
her idea that media is the one that influences us to believe that fighting
is normal. One of her examples is “Sara”. After watching the
movie When Harry Met Sally Sara thought it was cute and appropriate to
pick fights with her significant other and slap him through out the fights.
She also uses the movie, The Mexican, where the main characters have constant
conflict throughout the film, but of course in the end their love will
prevail and they will “live happily ever after”. The example
the Galician uses as a counter in the media is the song, The Light.
In this song the songwriter encourages that in order to have a successful
relationship one must have positive communication. I found that Galician’s
information aided me in getting the background information I needed to
start researching myth number eight. Although I found this to be
helpful she didn’t have the depth that we needed for our presentation so
this is what lead me to finding other sources like Gottman.
Gottman, J.M., & Silver, N. (1999). The seven principles
for making marriage work. New York: Three Rivers Press.
Gottman agrees with Galician in that conflict is not
a bad thing in relationships and it is essential in having a healthy relationship.
Gottman states that “Even happily married couples can have screaming matches-loud
arguments don’t’ necessarily harm a marriage”. This reinstates that
fighting in a relationship is normal and that screaming and yelling can
even be okay, but it’s the number of times that you fight that can potentially
harm your marriage and/or relationship. If your relationship is base
solely around fighting it will not be a successful relationship.
The communication and interactions in your relationship need to be mostly
positive but you must also balance that out with some negative interactions
as well. Those interactions can be small fights or they can be your
loud screaming matches. As long as you don’t allow them to control
your relationship you will be successful. Gottman was a very strong
source because he had a lot of research and he supported it well.
Nadig, Larry A. (2006, 12, 21). Guidelines on effective
communication, healthy relationships & successful living. Retrieved
October 16, 2007, from Larry Alan Nadig, Ph.D. Clinical Psychologist Marriage
and Family Therapist Web site: http://www.drnadig.com/
Dr. Nadig’s research is what really helped in me in
defining the difference between healthy and unhealthy conflict. He
was very adamant in agreeing with both Gottman and Galician in supporting
some conflict in the relationship. He focused mostly on resolving
the conflict in the relationships. Although this pertained more to
the prescription aspect on the speech his introduction helped me in his
talking about what conflict in relationships can do. He was
very supporting in saying conflict is the reality of the relationship and
that it is not necessarily bad. In his research and education he
has found that conflict can create deeper understanding and can establish
a stronger relationship. The statement that was the most important
from him that I really wanted my audience to understand was “How the conflicts
get resolved, not how many occur, is the critical factor in determining
whether a relationship will be healthy or unhealthy”. This is the
epitome in disillusioning this myth. People need to realize they
shouldn’t fight just to fight or avoid it just because that’s “right” conflict
happens and it can be healthy for your relationship. Dr. Nadig I
viewed as a very reliable source. He has a Ph.D. meaning he is very
educated and understands the research/experiments he has performed.
Advocates for Youth, (2002). Healthy vs. unhealthy relationships.
Retrieved October 18, 2007, from Advocates for Youth Web site: http://www.advocatesforyouth.org/youth/health/relationships/healthy.htm
This source I used very briefly, but I also found helpful
in my research. From this source I used the comparison table of unhealthy
relationships vs. healthy relationships. Although my topic was on
communication it helped to understand thoroughly the difference between
the two types of relationships. Some of the things listed in the
unhealthy side of the table were also things that could apparently cause
conflict in a relationship. An example of that would be, “One of
you has to justify what you do, where you go, and who you see.” This
could easily be a source of conflict if someone feels trapped in the relationship.
My goal was to convey to the audience was that conflict like this is completely
normal but what matters is how you would handle this conflict. I
couldn’t really go too in depth on this topic because that pertained more
to the prescription. I found this source to be very reliable.
It was an organization that was well represented and accredited.
The motive of this organization was to discourage against abusive and unhealthy
relationships. This was not what my topic was fully on so it did
not correlate perfectly with my topic, but some of the information it contained
was useful. |
|
Myth
9
|
Cutter, R. (1994). When Opposites Attract. New
York: Penguin Group.
By working with couples with communication problems,
Cutter concludes that gender is not what creates differences. She classifies
people as “right brained” or “left brained”. This book is designed to help
couples who are opposites work out their problems and communicate effectively.
She believes that just because two people have many differences doesn’t
mean they can’t be together. This book offers advice for couples, explains
unrealistic expectations many people hold, and shows dialogue of some couples
she has worked with. This book supports one part of Myth #9 by implying
that couples who have different values can be together, but goes against
it by saying that love is not all you need to make a relationship work.
Support in this myth, while also giving healthier ways to act in a relationship
made this book relevant and helpful to my research for the support of the
myth.
Edyvane, D. (2003). Against unconditional love. Journal
of Applied Philosophy, 20, 59-75.
This article by Edyvane works to disprove the belief
that the best type of love is unconditional.
The first part of the article takes a critical look
at what those say who defend unconditional love. They believe that conditional
love is love based on the properties of others, so that if those properties
change at all, so does the love. The second part of the article defends
conditional love. Edyvane is saying that even though one should not have
a list of qualities and love a person only if they retain these certain
qualities, one should have standards and not love illogically. This article
helped in my research by giving views of those who believe in unconditional
love, while showing arguments for conditional love. Myth #9 is basically
saying that love should be unconditional, so this article showed belief
in the myth. The main idea of the article showed the unhealthiness of this
belief and supported the prescription for this myth.
Jacobs, J.W. (2003, March). 7 myths that can kill your
marriage. Psychology Today, 34-42.
This article is about unrealistic expectations that
many people hold. These expectations lead to problems in marriages and
other long term relationships. It talks about the concept of soul mates,
commitment, conflict, differences between people, and working on individual
success versus working on relationships. In this article, seven commonly
held romantic myths are addressed, including “all you need is love” and
“great sex is easier than ever”. This article was beneficial to my research
because it talked about the unhealthy ideas people hold towards relationships.
It doesn’t support myth #9; by saying that shared values are important
in a relationship, it goes along with the prescription. John W. Jacobs
is a psychiatrist who has written a book on myths about marriage. |
|
Myth
10
|
Gorski, T. T. (1993). Getting love right: Learning
the choices of healthy intimacy. New York: Fireside.
I used this excerpt from Gorski’s book because
it gave an opinion to why we search for someone else to complete our lives.
Gorski also talked about how difficult, or impossible, it is to stay merged
with one person. He did say that we can find moments of “completeness,”
but he pointed out that we are individuals and we can never merge completely
with another person because of this. I found this excerpt useful
because it backed up my idea that we cannot merge into one person with
another person. It is impossible to create one whole person from
two half people.
Dreikurs, R. (1964). The challenge of marriage (9th
ed.). New York: Duell, Sloan, and Pearce.
This excerpt nailed the idea of Myth #10, you cannot
depend on destiny. If you rely on destiny to bring you the right mate to
complete you, you either will not find it or won’t recognize it.
This quote can also be tied in with myth #1 - You mate is cosmically predestined.
Nobody is one half of a person, this is just a thought engraved into us.
This excerpt tells us that we cannot sit around waiting for love, we need
to search for it. However, love isn’t perfect, and we need to realize
that a healthy relationship includes fighting and arguing.
Justin Luyt (n.d.). Romantic relationships: a spiritual
perspective. Retrieved October 25, 2007 from , KTL Enterprises
Pty. Ltd. Web site: http://www.spiritual.com.au/articles/relationships/romanticrelationships_jluyt.htm
This excerpt looked at a more fresh idea of myth #10.
The quote talks about viewing your partner’s beauty, however we clutch
to our partner to fill our emptiness. In reality, we cannot clutch
onto another person and expect to feel complete and whole. That is
too much dependence on our partner to provide us with emotional support.
Luyt explains that because we put so much pressure onto our relationship
for support, the relationship ends, generally resulting in a lot of pain.
We do not need someone to complete us, it is simply a “thought,” Luyt explains.
This quote was very helpful for supporting my speech, it gave an outlook
to myth #10 that was not completely negative, it was a more positive look
at why we feel like we need someone to complete us.
Buck, R. (2002). The genetics and biology of true love:
Prosocial biological affects and the left hemisphere. Psychological review,
109(4), 739-744.
The author of this article talks about the relationships
between the hemispheres of the mind and selfishness. The different
hemispheres right and left, control different functions of a person.
Emotions that might be related to selfishness, but are overlooked are sex,
bonding, and attachment. This article talks about true love being
hard to connect with biology or genes. No one knows which controls
whom you truly love. Prosocial biological affects can change the
two hemispheres by evolution some believe. This article is helpful
because it tells what emotions may affect love and also what other authors
have to say about love. It talks mainly on the scientific side of
emotions, which is helpful, but more research needs to be done to clarify
and elongate ideas. Ross Buck is credible through the University
of Connecticut in which he is writing for.
Diekman, A. B., McDonald, M., & Gardner, W. L. (2000).
Love means never having to be careful: The relationship between reading
romance novels and safe sex behavior. Psychology of Women Quarterly, 24(2),
179-188.
The media show love as swept off your feet and so in
love nothing could change the relationship. This article talks about
how the media influences women and their choice about condom usage.
For example romance book make sex look wonderful and safe, thus condoms
are not in the picture. Women now believe that taking time to use
a condom will ruin the mood and make sex less loving. The results
say that women need to be empowered to in the decision making about using
condoms. Love can be great while still being safe and careful.
This is a useful article because if gives examples on how the media affects
women. Reading romance novels can have the power to change your relationships.
It also gives many references that may be helpful to do other research.
These three authors are all from well-known universities and Cambridge
University Press published this article.
Segrin, C., & Taylor, M. (2007). Positive interpersonal
relationships mediate the association between social skills and psychological
well-being. Personality and Individual Differences, 43(4), 637-646.
The authors of this article talk about the connection
between social skills and psychological well- being. The article
shows survey results on the life satisfaction, positive relations with
others, environmental mastery and self- efficacy. Participants volunteered
to fill out questions and the questions were measured out into theses categories.
The results show that social skills are a main factor to positive psychological
happiness. This article was useful since it gave categories to what
makes people happy and it also states that interpersonal happiness is key
to social happiness. There were many references from this article
that could be useful for other sources. The other articles talked
about happiness, romantic relationships, and personality differences in
couples. This source is very recent being from 2007. The authors
are both professors of Communication at Arizona University and Bloomsburg
University. |
|
Myth
11
|
Boon, S.B., & Lomore, C.D. (2001). Admirer-celebrity
relationships among young adults, explaining the perceptions of celebrity
influence on identity. Human Communication Research, 27, 432-465.
This article is about a study done to evaluate the
relationship between celebrity idols and feelings of self-worth in teenage
to young adults. They took a survey to see the levels of attachment
and chose the participants accordingly. After analyzing their findings,
they then go on to discuss how their idols have influenced their feelings
of self-worth. This article was very helpful because it gave me a
lot of information about how we become attached to these TV/movie personalities.
It also showed how these relationships can affect us. It was interesting
to see how they especially affect the development of teenagers and young
adults.
Leets, L., De Becker, G., & Giles, H. (1995). Fans:
Exploring expressed motivation for contacting celebrities. Journal of Language
and Social Psychology, 14, 102-123.
The authors of this article wanted to focus on a different
aspect of communication in their research. They decided to look at
the visual affects. They went about this by analyzing fan letters
written to celebrities. They compared normal fan behavior with excessive
fan behavior. They wanted to see what makes people go to lengths
to contact these celebrities they do not even know. They came to the conclusion
that it has to do with the concept of Para-social relationships.
This article provided me with most of the information I needed to talk
about Para-social relationships. It was really helpful in explaining
the concept.
Key, W. B. (1993). Age of Manipulation, the Con in Confidence-the
Sin in Sincere. Maryland: Madison Books.
This book is about how the media uses techniques to
trick consumers into taking in messages that they present. The author
goes on to talk about how people believe that they are not being affected
by the media and that they can think for them selves. He talks about how
this is a big misconception because the media use several different techniques
to mold our minds and make us take things in that we might not if we were
consciously thinking about it. This book really helped me understand
how the media is not always the best source for information and that we
need to be able to filter what is true or not for ourselves. It gave
me the information I needed to present the tactics the media takes to subliminally
trick us to my audience in my speech.
Hoffner, C. A., Levine, K. J., Sullivan, Q. E., Crowell,
D., Pedrick, L., & Berndt, P. (2006). TV characters at work: Television's
role in the occupational aspirations of economically disadvantaged youths.
Journal of Career Development, 33(1), 3-18.
This article researches the correlation between occupational
portrayals of television characters and their affects on disadvantaged
youth. The authors of this article are professors from a range of Midwest
universities. In this study telephone interviews were conducted asking
people what their dream job was and who their favorite television character
was. Results showed that there was a positive correlation between the two
answers; the concept of this correlation is called wishful identification.
Wishful identification is a big part of my project, because it tells us
why we relate to actors. This article approaches two aspects of socialization:
firsthand experience and observation. This article states that because
disadvantaged youth do not usually have real life role models, they turn
to television which provides them many attractive role models that they
can determine their values and beliefs from. This article was very
interesting, because it researched in-depth about wishful identification
and how different occupations are portrayed as more glamorous and therefore
are more desired by youth. This was very useful, because it related
to my project by showing how actor’s characters influence us even if we
don’t see it. All of the sources used for this research were very current
and there were over forty-five different sources. The research taken for
the telephone interviews in this article was not done over a long period
of time; therefore, we do not know if the desired occupations would change
if the mass media changed what its glamorous occupations were. I
would recommend this article; I found this article very credible and useful
for my project.
McCourt, A., & Fitzpatrick, J. (2001). The role of
personal characteristics and romantic characteristics in parasocial relationships:
A pilot study.2(1)
This article was written by Matthew Thomson and researched
for the Journal of Marketing Affairs. This article researches people’s
attachments to celebrities and labels them “human brands”. This article
went into detail about different needs for attachments and why these attachments
matter to our society. Three different studies were designed to test the
validity of celebrity attachments and their influence. These studies were
very in-depth and professional. I found this article very helpful in providing
media examples of celebrity attachments. Since my project involved
the attachments people have to celebrities it was very useful to see what
these attachments were based off of and different aspects that make these
attachments weaker or stronger. Over sixty references were used to
create this article and most of them were scholarly journals. This
reference is very useful in presenting foundational concepts of celebrity
attachments.
Thomson, M. (2006). Human brands: Investigating antecedents
to consumers' strong attachments to celebrities. Journal of Marketing,
70(3), 104-119.
This article states that a person develops parasocial
relationships, because of his or her personal characteristics. The
authors’ research focuses mainly on parasocial relationships, the mass
media, and romance and friendship. This article was done for family
studies by the Texas Tech University. The authors examined characteristics
such as openness and loneliness as factors in developing unrealistic celebrity
relationships. Much of this article focuses on why certain people
develop stronger attachments, but does not extensively give information
concerning how to control theses attachments. I found this article
was interesting, because it provided me with reason why people become so
attached to actor’s characters. I could use a lot of information
in this article to explain how parasocial relationships form and how that
affects our real life relationships. I would recommend this article
as a good place to start when researching parasocial relationships, because
it covers a lot of basic information about different concepts and studies
versus focusing mainly on one concept. |